A recent NME review of Kassidy’s debut album, Hope Street, has caused a fair old storm, and in the process opened up a whole new debate.
I call what NME published a review, but it was basically an assault on the band by Jamie Crossan, where he labelled them “Topman mannequins masquerading as humans” and “a bunch of morons”, and failed to give any valid critique to explain why he disliked the album.
It’s hardly surprising to read such an article in the NME, the magazine is renowned for its band-bashing and cheap shots. I personally don’t read it anymore, and it seems I am not the only one who has long since turned off from the magazine.
I personally am not a big fan of Kassidy’s music. I reviewed the 1st EP and gave it a good write-up, which it deserved, but the following releases have not been to my taste. This post has nothing to do with whether I like the band or not, is certainly not a platform to bash them, and is simply a response to some of the current furore.
The review has garnered a lot of attention, with the link being shared on Facebook almost 800 times, and a barrage of responses ensuing. The comments on the review are littered with Kassidy fans showing their displeasure, and I’m sure some of the social network sharing has involved fans sticking up for the band.
The vast majority of what I have seen – this could be down to where I’m situated and the circles I keep – is people sharing the review, laughing about it, and basically enjoying Kassidy getting panned.
Kassidy’ stage manager feels this is due to one thing, stating on Facebook, “if you are in a band, in Glasgow, and become slightly successful, you will receive an unprovoked hatred towards you!”
This is a sentiment Hamish from the band shared in a BBC interview last year, saying:
“The Glasgow music scene is a fairly hostile place. Not many people support each other. If they do see any one of their peers – it could be their friends, it could be their family – doing anything they’re not, it becomes terribly hostile and they turn against you.”
It is a shame if a band feel like that, and I’m sure there are people hating on the band for various unfair reasons, but it doesn’t sound at all reflective of the unsigned scene in Glasgow to me.
There is simply more to the current wave of dislike for Kassidy than them being successful.
Look at the likes of Frightened Rabbit, Mogwai and Belle and Sebastian – all bands that came through the Glasgow music scene, and gained massive success, way beyond what Kassidy have achieved at this moment – where is the backlash for them? It’s more common for folk who supported them in the early days to wear their success as a badge of pride, and folk to mention their names proudly when talking of music in the city.
The band’s stage manager also commented on “the bitterness of the unsigned scene kids in Glasgow”. He believes “they should be thanking this band for attracting attention to the Glasgow music scene rather than doing the opposite”.
It’s definitely fair enough not to expect abuse from it, and it’s understandable to be annoyed by the online chiding, but Kassidy have simply never been part of an unsigned scene in Glasgow, so why should the band expect the support of said community?
Kassidy were signed to Vertigo Records – a major label that is home to the likes of The Killers, Metallica, and Razorlight – before having had a release or played a show, so there is bound to not be that affinity between the band and the unsigned scene.
I personally find it hard to believe that scouts will be flocking to unsigned gigs in Glasgow due to Kassidy – the band is not very representative of the music in the city. That’s not an attack on their tunes, it just seems obvious to me that the band don’t sound like what is popular in Glasgow, and have a far more mainstream sound, hence people who follow unsigned music in the city not taking to it.
Biffy Clyro have been darlings of Scottish music for a long time, but they have suffered a backlash of sorts recently. This is not due to them becoming successful, it’s due to them changing their style and playing very mainstream music, which was never going to sit well with the general gig-going punter.
Some people are going to be fickle and begrudge a band success, and those types of people are simply idiots. The Pop Cop recently wrote a great article about fans turning on bands when they become successful, and while this is prevalent, I don’t think it fits here.
The article also highlights (through my big online mouth) that what we put on the net often reaches the artist. It’s simply the way people communicate today – everything goes online and folk are going to voice their opinions this way, good or bad.
For every jibe at Kassidy there has been a rush of support from fans, which is good to see. I think people are within their rights to post their like or dislike about a band equally, and if it is a joke amongst friends then that’s their private conversation.
The NME review was extremely harsh, but I will still find the funny side to things like Kassidy being labelled “Crosby, Stills, and Gary Barlow”.
You don’t want to see folk getting a hard time though, and if it ever gets to the stage where a band are becoming some sort of pantomime villain then it has probably gone too far. I don’t think misguided outbursts at, what I find to be, a friendly and welcoming community help the cause though.
Russell Ferguson
April 5, 2011
very well put. I don’t find the Glasgow music scene hostile but I can sometimes see some malicious thoughts and intentions fired towards bands, most of the time it’s out of order. Great read this but!
Jimbo
May 31, 2011
Is there anything worse than musical snobbery? – which is what the NME article amounts to. That magazine long ago stopped being relevent and is today no more than the musical equivalent of women’s celebrity gossip mags. Okay, Kassidy do not represent the typical Glasgow band but it’s well crafted songs well sung. What’s the problem? Don’t like it? So what! As for the current Glasgow scene it’s in good shape and the next crop coming along, such as Selective Service, The Imagineers, The Replay and The Modests will do for me.
Favourite Son
April 5, 2011
cheers fella.
it definitely happens, but I fail to see it as the problem in this instance, or on such a big scale
evilstu
April 5, 2011
Great piece. Still never heard a song by Kassidy and don’t plan to, but it’s easy to see why they’re not liked by a DIY scene.
Loved the Starsailor tweet – almost feel sorry for the guy!!
Hamish
April 5, 2011
As much as I have some sympathies with what the band said, by saying it they’re opening themselves up to criticism from Glasgow. They’ve not got much to defend themselves with.
“If they do see any one … doing anything they’re not, it becomes terribly hostile and they turn against you.”
I definitely wouldn’t agree with that, it’s the fact that bands do something different that makes them successful (and I mean Frabbit, Mogwai, Belle & Sebastian type successful). Although I would say there is an element of bands being encouraged to do the same, especially now with so many post-Frabbit bands still sticking with that style (I like a lot of those bands, but it’s still frustrating that they make up the majority of the scene).
Very good post but.
Favourite Son
April 5, 2011
cheers fellas, much appreciated from folk live yourselves.
Stu – I did feel guilty after that, I didn’t expect him to see it, but (as The Pop Cop) showed social networking is far reaching.
Hamish – In fairness to the band, it doesn’t seem like they’ve retorted since the review. I just don’t see the ‘turn’ in people turning on them. There hasn’t been a before for there to be an after.
The Pop Cop
April 5, 2011
Personal attacks on any band like the one NME published here are totally uncalled for, unless of course the members of the band happen to be cocky little pricks who need to be taken down a peg or two. Irrespective of what you think of Kassidy’s music, I can say from first-hand experience that they are really decent, likeable guys so what NME did amounts to public bullying in my eyes.
I would however question your comment that “Kassidy were signed to Vertigo Records before having had a release or played a show” – I’m pretty sure that they were signed to their management company before playing a gig, but not so sure they had actually signed a record deal at that point… (?)
Hamish
April 5, 2011
Oh yeah, I’m absolutely against that NME review. I’ve never even listened to the band but it wasn’t just out of order, it was shoddy and lazy journalism. There wasn’t a single attempt in the review to actually describe the music other than the writer trying to show off how cynical he can be with the use of sub-standard puns.
Favourite Son
April 5, 2011
I agree, but I think the piece highlights that the NME article is ridiculous. I was aiming at a comment on what followed, and mentioned it was not a dig at Kassidy’s music.
I knew it was going to be hard to comment on that without it sounding like I am bashing them + I hope I didn’t do that.
I interviewed Lewis from the band at their 3rd gig at The Classic Grand + can say he is a really nice guy. He told me during that interview that they were signed before playing a show. If you are unsure then I’d say ask them
Favourite Son
April 6, 2011
Apologies, the last part of that comment does not sound as I intended.
I don’t have the interview on my dictaphone anymore, but from my recollection of the conversation believe the statement to be accurate.
I believe that, if asked, Kassidy would say the same thing, but if I am incorrect I will highlight this.
Reginald
April 12, 2011
Glad to see this post putting Jamie Crossan back in his box. I have followed Kassidy from their earliest days and they seem to split opinion more than any other band to come out of Scotland for a number of years. A large number of critiques focus heavily on their appearance more than their material (hippie wannabes etc) but do at the very least give an opinion on their music wether it be good, bad or indifferent. There was however no attempt from Crossan to offer his opinion on their album (of which I hear he stalked their PR for weeks to get his copy) and came across as a petty and very personal swipe at certain members of the band.
To confirm The Pop Cop’s point the band had played several gigs before signing with Vertigo, including a slot at King Tut’s which was wall to wall A+R with the deal being signed shortly afterwards. Do agree great piece on fans turning on successful bands.
Al
April 12, 2011
The Kassidy boys are a decent sort. Their music isn’t my favourite, as I think it’s a little by-numbers.
Jamie Crossan is a moron. He isn’t much of a writer and tries to gain a rep by slating bands unfairly.
Roo
May 6, 2011
I saw Kassidy play regularly every month for at least 8 months before they were signed including their first gig on Halloween at The Captains Rest with Paper Planes and The French Wives. They were never part of “the scene” to begin with so I can understand if they felt little support and why other bands could have been surprised at them being snapped up so fast. They have appealing music which does fit into the mainstream so perhaps this is why they got a deal so quick?
I know that the band have alot of musical friends in Glasgow.
I’m bored of this Jamie Crossan thing who cares?
Paul Docherty
May 6, 2011
Well written man. Glad to see some one with a sensible head. some things i have said have been rash and in the heat of the moment, Kassidy have never been embraced by the unsigned scene, but have plenty of friends in bands which are in unsigned acts. There are a majority of people in the “Glasgow Music Scene” who love to hate Kassidy, which is sad to see, at the end of the day, its music, an artform. Why be so hostile towards someone elses creativity? I think i am right in saying that these people are being bitter, but at the end of the day, its just my opinion.
Kudos on an honest and unbias opinion though.
A breath of fresh air.
Paul
Favourite Son
May 13, 2011
@Roo: Commenting I took that from an interview with Hamish from the band, and believed from what he said that it was true. It has been questioned a few times though, and I’d be keen to know aswell.
If it is inaccurate I will apologies, but it makes no diference to the point I was making. It was meant as a comment on the band being unknown to gig-goers in Glasgow, and to highlight the point that followed, and was certainly not a slight. Did u see what you would now call Kassidy playing in those preceeding months?
@Paul thanks for commenting, I was really keen to know your thoughts on the matter. The way you have responded is also refreshing, and I’m glad that someone close to the band has read the piece and not thought it was a bashing of Kassidy.
Any chance you could enlighten us on the gigs before being signed thing? My recollection is Hamish saying the first gig they played was a lable showcase, but by the sounds of it am wrong. Thanks
Paul MacDonald
May 13, 2011
All it shows is NME’s lack of editorial class, and if you ever needed a reasoning why those statistics show readership is going down – there you have it. I don’t know the background of Jamie Crossan, but looking at the first few google result, it appears he’s Scottish, so I suppose this is where the hostile Scottish background comes from?
Anyway – I CAN see where this Scottish ‘hostility’ comes from. There’s a lot of negative feeling when you hear of bands such as Kassidy, and lately Jack Townes, who have played very little yet achieved such success, and ease when it comes to getting festival slots, etc, which a lot of bands have to create momentum to even be considered for.
However, that said, especially in Jack Townes case, they are extremely supportive of the local scene. Regularly promoting gigs they have no involvement with on their facebook feeds and using the success they have enjoyed (supporting the view in their first few gigs) and tried to benefit others. I really like that.
^ Reminds me of what Alex Kapranos does with RM Hubert, Stuart Braithwaite with Twilight Sad/Errors/Remember Remember etc and countless of other examples. Supporting our local scene.
Kassidy, i know from good mates of mine, regularly go round folks houses and get the acoustics out. However I reckon they’ve been misrepresented online. The guys (from what i’ve heard) – we can establish are good guys – but comments like the BBC interview (was that a retaliation for the NME review?) do nothing but harm the Glasgow scene.. Furthermore, the comments by the stage manager rile me up as they emphasise this ‘holier than thou’ attitude we’re made to think Kassidy have. I am glad for their success, but after bands such as Mogwai/Belle and Sebastian/Franz Ferdinand/Biffy Clyro, we’ve got loads of exposure on the Glasgow scene.
Sorry for the long comment. I do think the Glasgow scene has a lot of support for each other though.
Jim
May 14, 2011
Devil’s advocate crossed with curiousity: why is it OK to slag off a band if they are dicks, but not if they are nice guys?
What do you do if you don’t like a band, but have never met them and have no idea what kind of people they are. Why should it matter?
Favourite Son
May 14, 2011
@ Paul No worries on the long comment, it’s good to hear your thoughts fella.
The BBC interview is well before the NME review, there might be dates on the links.
I don’t really want to comment on Jack Townes, I will have nothing constructive to say
Paul MacDonald
May 14, 2011
good point, Jim, it probably shouldn’t matter, but i guess you can feel justified in slagging a band off if you know that they’re full of dicks.
Also Jack Townes were definitely born with the silver spoon, but my point still stands that they seem to be promoting some folk.
Paul Docherty
May 14, 2011
No worries man! The piece is totally unbiased, of course people arent going to like Kassidy, but there is no need for the hostility towards them.
Before the boys were signed they used to practice 5 days a week and gigged regularly around the Glasgow circut in 2007/2008 with bands such as Astral Planes, French Wives, Pearl and the Puppets to name a few. The boys definately put in a lot of ground work before A&R started coming to gigs, just to set the record straight.
@ Paul, again thanks for your honesty man, the “holier than thou attitude” that apparently comes across is totally not how Kassidy try or want to come across. We love going out to gigs in the unsigned circut, seeing the obvious talent Glasgow has. As for the Biffy/Mogwai/Frabbit comment, you are quite right, but my point was, now in Glasgow, it seems to be different cliques as you probably know, and Kassidy were never embraced by any of these, this is why i feel a lot of people may be bitter as they think Kassidy have just appeared out of thin air with a record contract, when it isnt the case at all.
cheers
Paul
Paul Docherty
May 14, 2011
@ Jim
At the end of them why are you “slagging bands off” at all?
You have proved my point exactly.
Favourite Son
May 15, 2011
@ Paul Doc I think Jim was referring to an earlier comment
Jim
May 16, 2011
I didn’t slag anyone off, I just asked a question.
rhonda
May 26, 2011
I have followed bands for years.. Born in the early 60`s I have paid good money to see the Stones would not miss a tour, Clapton, Genysis, Prince in the 80`s to name but a few. I love new bands that actually play music and can sing, James Walsh, Brandon Flowers, Scissor Sisters and the Jam to P Weller solo, Barrowlands Glasgow, played Glasgow a number of times. Music plays a massive roll in people`s lives and to hear a band such as Kassidy come along, slick, effortless and dedicated to music who gives the right to say something negative on a personal note not a professional note. It is a true saying music speaks for itself, you only have to look at` SOLD OUT` when attempting to buy a very low priced ticket for exceptional quality music that can only make an audience feel part of that. The writer touches on `looks` a point they do not need to make or share, a reflection on the writer. Kassidy are no doubt a up and coming band who deserve to be recognised, again be there in a room` full of people` focused on MUSIC. Is that not what life should be about? I think the writer should think again and look more closely at what the public want and each day Kassidy grow stronger and there is no doubt will deliver even more excellent music. Debate of music has a place but personal attack should not be on the agenda. If you have something to say as a writer from any walk of life you should be able to speak with facts and not what just emotion, will always take time to listen to new music, as said before it is part of our lives. R
steve the budgie
June 20, 2011
Jim says: “I fell for Kassidy (or “Cassidy” as they were then known) the first time I saw them live. That was early 2009 I think, when they appeared at Glasgow’s Admiral Bar at a Dykeenies single launch. The next time I saw them was at King Tut’s, when you could hardly move for record company A&R folk. No surprise then that they were soon snapped up by Mercury Records. After a debut release through King Tut’s Recordings, things progressed quite nicely for the boys…despite the occasional “small” hiccup like ditching the album they’d recorded, and starting again! My wife Candy’s already swiped my copy of Hope St, and it’s her current favourite in the car. I married a lady with taste! Waking Up Sideways is futher proof that Kassidy are a band on the rise.”
The mirror man
January 13, 2013
You should read calm as the colour’s review in is this music? absolutely shocking